Decision workflow

Ruling Assistant

Pick the issue type, mark the live conditions, and walk through the checklist before any commissioner call, council review, or league vote becomes the final ruling.

Back to bylaws Pending items

Issue Intake

Select the closest issue, then mark whether this is urgent, conflicted, or evidence-ready.

Issue type

Emergency freeze may be needed before the action becomes impossible to unwind. The commissioner is directly involved and should recuse. Timestamped evidence has been collected.

Trade reversal or collusion claim

The ruling path updates when issue conditions change.

Quick Ruling Checklist

Progress saves in this browser so the same ruling path can be resumed during a dispute.

0 / 8

Is Yahoo already enforcing the outcome? What exact Yahoo setting or written rule applies? Is the commissioner directly involved and required to recuse? Was the dispute filed on time? What timestamped evidence exists? Is the requested remedy reversible and fair to non-involved teams? Is this a one-off ruling or future precedent? Does this require a vote or bylaws update?